What a Board Should Ask for in a Roof Report
By Andrew Goodrick, Canton, Georgia
A roof report is only useful if a board can act on it. That means it has to answer four questions, in writing, for each building: what condition is this roof in, how much life is left in it, what needs doing now, and what will it cost. A report that does not answer those four is a walk-through note, not a report, and a board should not vote on the strength of one.
Start with photos. Every problem the report names should have a photo with it, and the photo should be labeled with the building and the location on that roof. A photo of a lifted shingle means little on its own. A photo labeled with the building number, the slope, and the detail that failed is something a board can file and a roofer can find again next year. Ask for the photos to be dated. Roofs change slowly, and a date is what turns a photo into a record.
Next, the condition of each building, separately. A community report that averages its buildings together hides the one that needs work. Each building gets its own line: the roof covering, its visible condition, the flashing, the vents and pipe boots, the gutters, and an estimate of remaining service life. Remaining life is an estimate, not a promise, and a roofer who will not put a number on it is not giving the board what it needs to plan. A range is fine. "Three to five years" is more honest than a single year, and it is enough to budget on.
Pricing should be broken out by building and by job, not lumped into one community total. A board needs to see what the worst building costs apart from the rest, because that is usually the decision in front of them: fix this building now, or watch it for another year. If the report proposes work, each item should say what it is, where it is, and what it costs. Vague lines like "miscellaneous repairs" should be sent back for detail. A board cannot approve what it cannot read.
Finally, ask the roofer to separate urgent work from watch items. A leak into a living space is urgent. A pipe boot that is cracking but still shedding water is a watch item with a date on it. A report that marks everything urgent is not helping anyone prioritize, and a report that marks nothing urgent has not looked hard enough. The split between the two columns is where the board's judgment lives, and the roofer's job is to make that judgment possible.
Keep the report with the inspection notes. In two years, when the next report arrives, the comparison between the two is the most valuable thing the board owns. It shows whether the roofs are aging the way the last report said they would, and whether the money spent since then went to the right buildings.