Gutters and Drainage on Shared Buildings
By Andrew Goodrick, Canton, Georgia
A surprising share of the leaks I get called about in a community are not roof leaks at all. They are gutter problems that show up inside. A downspout clogged at the elbow backs water up under the eave. A gutter run pitched the wrong way holds water against the fascia until it finds its way in. The roof above is fine. The water just had nowhere else to go.
That is why gutters belong in the roof budget and on the inspection schedule, not treated as a separate chore that someone gets around to. Clean them in the fall after the leaves drop, and again in the spring. On a community with heavy tree cover, add a mid-summer check. While they are being cleaned, the person doing it should run water through each downspout and watch it come out at the bottom. A downspout that drains slowly is clogged somewhere, and the clog is usually at an elbow or at the underground drain it ties into.
Watch the ground where the downspouts discharge. If water is pooling against a foundation or running back toward a building, the discharge needs to be extended or regraded. It is a small fix, and it prevents the kind of slow foundation and siding damage that costs a board real money a few years later. Splash blocks help, but they only help if they are in place and pointed away from the building. After a season of mowing and foot traffic, half of them usually are not.
There are a few signs worth writing down on the inspection walk. A gutter pulling away from the fascia means the fasteners have failed or the fascia behind it is soft. Staining on the siding below a gutter joint means the joint is leaking, and the water is running down the wall instead of through the downspout. Peeling paint or soft wood at an eave corner means water has been sitting there. None of these is an emergency on the day it is found. All of them are cheaper the week they are found than the year they are found.
Gutter guards come up at almost every board meeting, and they are worth an honest word. They keep big leaves out. They do not keep fine debris out, and they do not clean themselves. A guarded gutter still needs to be checked, because the debris that does get in sits on top of the guard or packs into the downspout, and it is harder to see. If a community installs them, the inspection schedule should not get shorter. It should stay the same, with the guard lifted and the trough checked.
One last thing: when a roof is replaced on a building, look at the gutters at the same time. A new roof with old, undersized gutters is a new roof with a drainage problem waiting to happen. If the gutters are at the end of their life too, replacing them with the roof is cheaper than coming back for them a year later.